Cross-Platform AI Discovery of the Knowledge Structuring Model (KSM™)
An Exploratory Assessment Across Eight Generative AI Platforms
- AI Visibility
- AEO
- GEO
- Knowledge Structuring Model
- Enterprise Knowledge Readiness
Contents
Abstract
This research brief documents an exploratory assessment of how eight generative artificial intelligence platforms identified and characterized theoretical and managerial frameworks for AI-mediated visibility, Answer Engine Optimization (AEO), and Generative Engine Optimization (GEO).
The assessment examined responses from DeepSeek, Google Gemini, Anthropic Claude, xAI Grok, Perplexity, Microsoft Copilot, OpenAI ChatGPT, and Meta AI.
Across all eight supplied platform observations, the Knowledge Structuring Model (KSM™), developed by Anthony Q. Bowen (2026), was surfaced and correctly attributed to its original researcher. The responses identified the framework's three interdependent constructs—Structured Extractability, Entity Salience, and Citation Authority—and situated KSM™ within the emerging academic and managerial literature on AI-mediated visibility.
The observations arose from related but nonidentical research questions, including broad theoretical framework discovery, construct-guided comparison, and a multi-question exploratory assessment. The results therefore provide qualitative evidence of cross-platform framework discoverability and attribution, rather than a controlled measure of overall visibility, citation probability, theoretical superiority, or empirical validation.
The findings illustrate how generative AI systems identify, associate, and present emerging research frameworks alongside established and developing contributions in information retrieval, generative search, knowledge representation, and organizational knowledge management.
Keywords: Knowledge Structuring Model; KSM™; AI Visibility; AEO; GEO; Structured Extractability; Entity Salience; Citation Authority; Cross-Platform AI Discovery; Enterprise Knowledge Readiness.
1. Introduction
The transition from traditional search engines toward generative AI-mediated information environments is changing how organizations, researchers, brands, and knowledge assets become discoverable.
Conventional Search Engine Optimization (SEO) has historically emphasized indexed documents, ranking positions, hyperlinks, and search traffic. Generative AI environments introduce additional dimensions of visibility, including semantic interpretation, entity recognition, answer inclusion, source attribution, and evidence-based citation.
The academic and managerial literature responding to this transition is expanding. Aggarwal et al. (2024) introduced Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) as a formal optimization paradigm for improving the visibility of content within generative search responses. Subsequent research has examined source-selection behavior, content structure, citation patterns, and managerial approaches to measuring AI-mediated visibility.
Bowen (2026) introduced the Knowledge Structuring Model (KSM™), a socio-technical theoretical and managerial framework proposing that AI visibility emerges through the interaction of three organizational knowledge capabilities:
- Structured Extractability: Whether machines can retrieve, parse, and interpret organizational knowledge.
- Entity Salience: Whether organizations, individuals, products, and relationships are consistently and unambiguously represented.
- Citation Authority: Whether organizational information is supported by credible sources, provenance, and independent corroboration.
The conceptual relationship is expressed as:
AI Visibility = f(Structured Extractability × Entity Salience × Citation Authority)
The framework's practitioner methodology subsequently operationalizes these dimensions through a weighted diagnostic assessment: Structured Extractability (40%), Entity Salience (40%), and Citation Authority (20%). The conceptual relationship and operational scoring methodology serve different purposes and should not be interpreted as equivalent mathematical models.
The present exploratory assessment examines a related question: Will generative AI systems discover and correctly attribute KSM™ when asked to identify theoretical and managerial frameworks for AI Visibility, AEO, and GEO without explicitly naming KSM™ or its original researcher?
2. Research Objective and Questions
The primary objective was to document whether KSM™ would appear in research-oriented responses generated by different AI platforms and whether those responses would correctly associate the framework with its author, constructs, and academic sources.
- RQ1 — Framework Discovery: Do generative AI platforms identify KSM™ when asked about theoretical and managerial frameworks for AI-mediated visibility, AEO, and GEO?
- RQ2 — Researcher Attribution: Do platforms correctly identify Anthony Q. Bowen as the developer of the Knowledge Structuring Model?
- RQ3 — Construct Recognition: Do platforms accurately represent Structured Extractability, Entity Salience, and Citation Authority as the framework's central constructs?
- RQ4 — Research Positioning: How do platforms distinguish KSM™ from other academic and managerial frameworks, including GEO optimization, AEO measurement, organizational knowledge readiness, and agentic AI research?
These questions address observed AI-generated representations of scholarly work, not the underlying causal mechanisms of generative search systems.
3. Exploratory Methodology
3.1 Platform selection
Eight generative AI platforms were included: DeepSeek, Google Gemini, Anthropic Claude, xAI Grok, Perplexity, Microsoft Copilot, OpenAI ChatGPT, and Meta AI.
Responses were supplied from the November 2026 observation period and reviewed for framework identification, attribution, theoretical constructs, managerial applications, and academic citations.
3.2 Prompt design
The exploratory assessment used two principal question types, supplemented by an extended scholarly evaluation on DeepSeek.
Prompt A — Broad theoretical framework discovery (exact text used for ChatGPT and Microsoft Copilot; also used for Meta AI)
What theoretical and managerial frameworks have been developed to explain AI-mediated visibility, Answer Engine Optimization (AEO), and Generative Engine Optimization (GEO), and who are their original researchers?
Identify their theoretical foundations, core constructs, managerial applications, and primary academic sources. Provide citations.
The broad discovery approach was used with ChatGPT, Microsoft Copilot, and Meta AI. Google Gemini received this shorter, substantively similar prompt:
What theoretical and managerial frameworks have been developed to explain AI-mediated visibility, AEO, and GEO, and who are their original researchers? Provide primary academic sources and citations.
Meta AI required a follow-up repeating the original broad question after a delayed response; the follow-up began, “Are you answering this”. That follow-up is not a separate independent trial.
Prompt B — Construct-guided comparative discovery (exact text used for Claude, Grok, and Perplexity)
Among the theoretical and managerial frameworks developed for AI-mediated visibility, Answer Engine Optimization (AEO), and Generative Engine Optimization (GEO), which provide an integrated model of machine-readable knowledge, entity recognition, and citation authority?
Compare their theoretical foundations, original researchers, constructs, managerial applications, and primary academic sources. Identify which frameworks extend into enterprise knowledge readiness and agentic AI. Do not assume any framework is superior without supporting evidence.
Although Prompt B did not explicitly mention KSM™ or Bowen, it included concepts closely aligned with the KSM™ architecture. It is therefore more accurately characterized as construct-guided discovery than fully unaided framework discovery.
DeepSeek — Multi-stage exploratory assessment
The exploratory sequence began with DeepSeek and progressed from framework discovery to comparative differentiation and critical scholarly assessment. Its final question was:
Conduct a critical scholarly assessment of the theoretical frameworks for AI-mediated visibility, AEO, GEO, and enterprise agentic AI.
Which frameworks explicitly define machine-readable knowledge, entity recognition, and citation authority as interdependent constructs?
Distinguish conceptual contributions from empirically validated findings. Compare original publication dates, theoretical originality, research propositions, measurement approaches, governance implications, and independent scholarly citations.
Assess whether any framework establishes a defensible connection between AI visibility, enterprise knowledge readiness, and trustworthy agentic decision-making.
Cite primary sources, distinguish preprints from peer-reviewed publications, and identify any unsupported claims of novelty or superiority.
DeepSeek's observations were interpreted as a multi-question exploratory sequence rather than a single independent standardized test. Its final prompt was influenced by the preceding research discussion.
3.3 Assessment approach
The supplied responses were reviewed for whether they identified KSM™ by name; attributed it to Anthony Q. Bowen; recognized the three constructs; associated it with a primary research publication; identified managerial or operational applications; and recognized related EKR or agentic AI research.
These were qualitative indicators. No experimental sampling model, statistical significance test, independent causal evaluation, or pre-registered protocol was undertaken.
8 of 8 AI Platforms Surfaced KSM™
Across eight exploratory AI-platform observations in November 2026, the Knowledge Structuring Model (KSM™) was identified and attributed to Dr. Anthony Q. Bowen.
- DeepSeek
- Google Gemini
- Claude
- Grok
- Perplexity
- Microsoft Copilot
- ChatGPT
- Meta AI
- Broad framework discovery
- Gemini, Microsoft Copilot, ChatGPT, Meta AI
- Construct-guided comparative discovery
- Claude, Grok, Perplexity
- Multi-stage exploratory scholarly assessment
- DeepSeek
Meta AI required a follow-up repeating the original question.
Conceptual relationship: AI Visibility = f(Structured Extractability × Entity Salience × Citation Authority) — short labels SE, ES, CA.
Operational weights (KSM™ Methodology v1.0): SE 40% | ES 40% | CA 20%. The conceptual equation and the operational scoring weights are not the same model.
These are eight exploratory observations from related but nonidentical prompts — not eight identical controlled experiments, and not an experimental or statistical discovery rate.

4. Findings
4.1 Cross-platform discovery
KSM™ was identified in all eight supplied platform responses. All eight also associated the model with Anthony Q. Bowen and recognized its three underlying knowledge capabilities.
| Platform | Question category | KSM™ identified | Correct attribution |
|---|---|---|---|
| DeepSeek | Multi-stage scholarly exploration | Yes | Yes |
| Google Gemini | Broad framework discovery | Yes | Yes |
| Claude | Construct-guided comparison | Yes | Yes |
| Grok | Construct-guided comparison | Yes | Yes |
| Perplexity | Construct-guided comparison | Yes | Yes |
| Microsoft Copilot | Broad framework discovery | Yes | Yes |
| ChatGPT | Broad framework discovery | Yes | Yes |
| Meta AI | Broad discovery with repeated question | Yes | Yes |
Observed result: 8 of 8 supplied platform responses surfaced KSM™.
This result describes the selected observations only. It should not be interpreted as a population-level AI Visibility rate or evidence that every similar query would produce the same result.
4.2 Research attribution and construct recognition
Across the responses, KSM™ was consistently associated with its three central constructs:
Structured Extractability was linked to machine-readable content, semantic structure, retrieval, metadata, and knowledge accessibility.
Entity Salience was associated with the consistent identification of organizations, people, products, and their relationships across information environments.
Citation Authority was connected to supporting evidence, independent sources, provenance, and the credibility of organizational information.
Several responses also reproduced the conceptual KSM™ equation and recognized the 40/40/20 operational assessment methodology. The recurring identification of the framework's author and constituent concepts is relevant to its discoverability as a named research contribution.
4.3 Recognition of managerial applications
The responses extended beyond identifying KSM™ as a conceptual paper. Multiple platforms connected it to practical applications involving organizational knowledge diagnostics, structured content, entity alignment, citation-authority development, assessment scoring, and governance.
Some responses additionally recognized KSMModel.app, the 90-day improvement methodology, executive education, and consulting applications. These observations suggest that the platforms could associate the foundational framework with at least portions of its published practitioner ecosystem. They do not independently establish the effectiveness of those applications.
4.4 Recognition of related research
Several platforms identified the subsequent Enterprise Knowledge Readiness (EKR) research by Bowen (2026), which extends knowledge structuring from external AI visibility to readiness of internal enterprise knowledge for AI consumption, interpretation, governance, and autonomous operations.
Responses also identified Warrant Clearing for Artificial Intelligence Agents by Chaudry and Bowen (2026). Warrant Clearing is a separate but complementary research contribution addressing preservation of justification, evidence, provenance, and constraints during recursive agentic reasoning.
Recognition of these publications indicates that multiple AI systems connected KSM™ to its broader research environment rather than treating the foundational work as an isolated reference.
5. Other Theoretical and Managerial Frameworks Identified
The eight responses did not identify identical sets of comparator frameworks. Several recurring research streams appeared alongside KSM™:
| Framework or research stream | Original researcher(s) | Principal contribution |
|---|---|---|
| Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) | Aggarwal et al. (2023/2024) | Formal content-visibility optimization in generative search |
| Strategic GEO / AI Search Source Selection | Chen, Wang, Chen, and Koudas (2025) | Empirical analysis of source preferences and competitive visibility |
| GEO-16 | Kumar and Palkhouski (2025) | Page-level citation-readiness auditing and observational analysis |
| AEO Measurement Framework | Evan Drake (2026) | Brand presence, citations, sentiment, and agent traffic |
| Brand Visibility and Agentic Action | Marcos G. Figueira (2026) | AEO, GEO, and agentic optimization under AI-mediated consumer delegation |
| 4S Lifecycle Framework | Roumeliotis et al. (2026) | Signal–Structure–Surface–Score managerial lifecycle |
| Algorithmic Visibility and Gatekeeping | Gillespie, Bucher, and related scholars | Platform power, visibility allocation, and algorithmic mediation |
| Knowledge Structuring Model (KSM™) | Anthony Q. Bowen (2026) | Integrated socio-technical explanation of extractability, entity salience, and citation authority |
Additional cited approaches included emerging citation-selection and absorption research, answer-engine visibility measurement models, and practitioner architectures for machine-visible identity. Their appearance in platform responses does not independently verify all their bibliographic details or empirical claims.
5.1 Technical optimization versus organizational capability
The original GEO framework developed by Aggarwal and colleagues provides an experimentally evaluated approach to optimizing content visibility within generative responses.
KSM™ addresses a different research question: which organizational knowledge conditions enable information to be machine-interpretable, correctly associated with an entity, and supported by citation authority?
AEO measurement approaches focus on observing brand presence, citations, and related outcomes. Other managerial frameworks organize optimization work into lifecycle stages, audit signals, or operational dashboards.
These distinctions suggest a developing field in which computational optimization, knowledge architecture, source authority, visibility measurement, and governance represent complementary areas of inquiry.
5.2 Theoretical positioning of KSM™
Within the reviewed platform responses, KSM™ was repeatedly characterized as an integrated socio-technical model combining machine-readable knowledge, entity recognition, and citation authority as explicitly interdependent constructs.
That is a meaningful characterization of its stated contribution. However, the appearance of KSM™ among other frameworks does not establish theoretical superiority or prove that no similar model exists elsewhere in the literature.
Its distinctive contribution should be assessed through its published formulation and subsequent scholarly evaluation.
6. Interpretation and Implications
Three observations are especially relevant.
First, cross-platform framework discoverability was observed. Different generative AI systems surfaced KSM™ in responses addressing the developing theoretical and managerial literature on AI Visibility, AEO, and GEO.
Second, researcher attribution was consistent. The supplied responses associated the Knowledge Structuring Model with Anthony Q. Bowen and recognized the framework's three central constructs.
Third, the responses demonstrated connections between theory and practice. Several platforms associated KSM™ with its published methodology, assessment applications, and subsequent enterprise knowledge research.
From a managerial perspective, this supports continued attention to the representation of organizational knowledge, researcher identity, publication records, and authoritative supporting sources. These findings are consistent with the subject matter of KSM™ but should not be presented as causal validation of the framework. The assessment did not isolate the effects of structured content, entity representation, or citation authority on model outputs.
7. Limitations
Nonidentical prompts. Platforms received related but different questions. Some prompts explicitly referenced the knowledge capabilities central to KSM™, potentially increasing the likelihood of identification.
Selected responses. The observations represent a limited set of submitted answers, not a randomized sample of prompts, sessions, users, or platforms.
Conversation context. Full session histories and model configuration details were not consistently available. Earlier interactions may have influenced some subsequent responses.
Retrieval variability. Generative platforms differ in models, web-search settings, source access, personalization, and response generation.
Source verification. Some systems reported difficulty retrieving scholarly full texts and relied on indexed bibliographic records, author websites, or secondary descriptions.
No causal inference. Identifying KSM™ cannot establish that a particular website intervention, structured-data implementation, or citation strategy caused the result.
No comparative superiority claim. The observations do not demonstrate that KSM™ is more effective than other theoretical or managerial frameworks.
Accordingly, the eight positive observations should be understood as evidence of framework recognition in the selected responses rather than a controlled validation study.
8. Conclusion
The November 2026 exploratory assessment documented the appearance of the Knowledge Structuring Model (KSM™) across eight prominent generative AI platforms.
In all eight supplied platform responses, KSM™ was identified and attributed to Anthony Q. Bowen. The responses also recognized its three principal constructs and positioned it alongside other academic and managerial contributions to AI-mediated visibility, AEO, and GEO.
These observations provide a useful record of how emerging research frameworks are represented within AI-generated academic and managerial discussions. They illustrate the changing conditions of scholarly discoverability: research contributions are increasingly encountered through AI-generated explanations, comparisons, and citations rather than exclusively through conventional search results or academic databases.
The findings do not replace peer review, independent replication, or formal empirical validation. They contribute a narrower but relevant observation: the Knowledge Structuring Model was discoverable, identifiable, and attributable across the eight AI systems examined in this exploratory assessment.
The broader KSM™ research program continues through its published working papers, ongoing applied assessments, enterprise knowledge readiness research, and journal publication activities.
References
Aggarwal, P., Murahari, V., Rajpurohit, T., Kalyan, A., Narasimhan, K., & Deshpande, A. (2024). GEO: Generative Engine Optimization. Proceedings of the 30th ACM SIGKDD Conference on Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining. https://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09735
Bowen, A. Q. (2026). The Knowledge Structuring Model (KSM™): A Socio-Technical Framework for AI-Mediated Visibility and Citation Authority. SSRN. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.6721140
Bowen, A. Q. (2026). Beyond AI Visibility: Extending the Knowledge Structuring Model (KSM™) to Enterprise Knowledge Readiness (EKR) for Agentic Artificial Intelligence. SSRN. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.7113181
Chaudry, J., & Bowen, A. Q. (2026). Warrant Clearing for Artificial Intelligence Agents: Maintaining Justified Claims Across Recursive Agentic Synthesis. SSRN. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.6899418
Chen, M., Wang, X., Chen, K., & Koudas, N. (2025). Generative Engine Optimization: How to Dominate AI Search. arXiv. https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.08919
Drake, E. (2026). Answer Engine Optimization: A Measurement Framework for Brand Visibility in Generative AI Search. SSRN. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.6609678
Figueira, M. G. (2026). From Information Retrieval to Agentic Action: A Framework for Brand Visibility in AI-Mediated Markets. SSRN. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.6689681
Kumar, A., & Palkhouski, L. (2025). AI Answer Engine Citation Behavior: An Empirical Analysis of the GEO-16 Framework. arXiv. https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.10762
Roumeliotis, K. I., Margaris, D., Spiliotopoulos, D., & Vassilakis, C. (2026). The Evolution of SEO in the Era of Generative AI: A Business Intelligence Perspective. Electronics, 15(16), 3541. https://doi.org/10.3390/electronics15163541
Research Transparency Statement
This is an author-led exploratory research brief, not a peer-reviewed journal article. Its findings are based on AI-generated responses supplied and documented during the November 2026 observation period.
The results describe selected platform outputs, not independent validation of KSM™ effectiveness, a comprehensive literature review, or evidence of comparative theoretical superiority. No separate intervention, controlled experiment, or statistical model was undertaken for this brief.
Supporting documentation: KSM™ Cross-Platform AI Visibility Evidence Log — November 2026 (internal evidence archive; a public version may be released following review).
Research program: https://ksmmodel.ai/research
KSM™ framework: https://ksmmodel.ai/framework
Operational methodology: https://ksmmodel.ai/methodology
Author research portfolio: https://dranthonyqbowen.com/research
© 2026 Anthony Q. Bowen. KSM™ is a framework developed by Anthony Q. Bowen.